Over the past few months, my leadership team has been experimenting with the DISC communication model popularized by Thomas Erikson in books like Surrounded by Idiots and Surrounded by Bad Bosses.

For the more experienced managers, applying DISC came naturally. They were able to quickly recognize different personality types in their teams and adapt their communication styles. The results were obvious: smoother collaboration, fewer misunderstandings and faster delivery.

But not everyone had the same experience.

When DISC didn’t work

One of my less experienced managers was struggling. He understood the model in theory, but he couldn’t confidently assign personality types to his team members. Because of that, his attempts to adapt communication often felt off.

When we spoke, I realized his problem wasn’t knowledge, it was a lack of a simple, practical way to identify types in real conversations. So I gave him a quick exercise.

The Elevator Story

Here’s the story I told John to use with his team:

“Imagine we are all in the office and our next team meeting is on another floor. We gather as a group and head toward the elevator. What do you do?”

Then, offer four possible answers:

  1. The Red Type (Dominant): You rush ahead, press the call button first and make sure the elevator goes to the right floor as quickly as possible.
  2. The Blue Type (Analytical): You check the sign inside the elevator showing the maximum capacity. You calculate quickly if the whole group can fit safely.
  3. The Green Type (Supportive): You stand near the panel to hold the doors and make sure everyone gets in before you let them close.
  4. The Yellow Type (Expressive): You tell a funny story from last weekend, so absorbed in entertaining the group that you barely notice the elevator ride itself.

Most people laugh, but they also instantly recognize themselves and in that moment, their dominant color becomes visible without long questionnaires or abstract theory.

How a simple elevator story helped my team use the DISC model more effectively

What Happened Next

John used this little story with his team. Suddenly, the DISC model stopped being a confusing concept and became a shared language. His team started to understand each other better and John gained confidence in tailoring his communication.

Within weeks, we saw the difference:

  • Team efficiency improved.
  • They delivered more projects with fewer conflicts.
  • Collaboration became smoother and lighter.

All because John had a tool simple enough to use in everyday conversations.

The Takeaway

The DISC model is powerful, but only if leaders can make it practical. My advice to new managers is this: don’t get lost in the theory. Instead, start with small, relatable tools, like the elevator story.

When people recognize themselves in a simple situation, the rest of the model suddenly makes sense and once that happens, you’ll see the same thing we did: less friction, better results and teams that actually enjoy working together.